Saturday, October 23, 2010

Weekly Roundup: NPR / Fox News analyst Juan Williams firing sparks questions on broadcaster’s public funding.

Firestorm of the Week

NPR fires Juan Williams. Right in an uproar. Left yawns.

The long time NPR correspondent, Juan Williams, who frequently appears on Fox News, was fired this week for statements made on the O’Reilly Factor show. Here is the full text:

Political correctness can lead to some kind of paralysis where you don't address reality. I mean, look Bill [O'Reilly], I'm not a bigot, you know the kind of books I've written on the civil rights movement in this country, but when I get on a plane, I got to tell you, if I see people who are in Muslim garb and I think, you know, they are identifying themselves first and foremost as Muslims, I get worried. I get nervous. Now, I remember also that when the Times Square bomber was at court, I think this was just last week. He said the war with Muslims, America's war is just beginning, first drop of blood. I don't think there's any way to get away from these facts. But I think there are people who want to somehow remind us all as President Bush did after 9/11, it's not a war against Islam

Pundits and Analysts Respond

The main arguments from both sides can be summed up quickly:

Left: Juan Williams is an at-will employee who's comments contradict NPR's journalistic standards resulting in a justifiable dismissal. But not everyone on the left is lending their support.

Right: Juan Williams made uncomfortable but truthful remarks, but his firing infringes his freedom of speech and justifies revoking public funding for NPR.

“You said what? You’re fired!”

Juan Williams follows Helen Thomas and Rick Sanchez to complete the rule of three and demonstrates that outrage over a firing is common in both ends of the political spectrum. Although the players are different the argument is the same - what are a journalist's obligations regarding their personal opinions? What are the lines for political correctness? Is a firing in the name of objectivity an infringement of free speech? Christian Science Monitor thinks the issue is less about objectivity and more about transparency.

Did NPR fire Williams because of his affiliation with Fox News or because of their own intolerance? What should be the repercussion?

The right is pretty united, DeMint and Boehner have both suggested they will look to revoke funding to the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Andrew McCarthy thinks an attempt to defund the CPB is a good test run to gauge the GOP's ability to repeal Health Care reform bills. However, not everyone thinks it will be so easy.

On the upside, we were treated to a wide array of replacements for the NPR acronym:

  • National Private Radio
  • National Pathetic Radio
  • National Politburo Radio etc.

Further reading from the right:

  • Fox News - Defund NPR
  • Michelle Malkin - Defund NPR
  • WSJ - Defund NPR, not because the firing was wrong, but but out of a distaste for subsidy in general.

You can bet on this conversation continuing. Everyone likes to point out the other guys hypocrisy. Add in the inevitable campaign promises to pull the money from a left-wing propaganda machine and we have a conversation piece that will last until election day.

Juan Williams may have been fired for saying what many of us are thinking, but what we really need is an open productive discussion of the roots of those thoughts and the biases inside all of us.

(Full Disclosure: The author of this post is one of the "listeners like you")

Tom Brokaw asks - the Media Answers

Monday, New York Times: Tom Brokaw wonders aloud why the war in Afghanistan is getting so little press. Noting that domestic issues are the subject of the opinion pieces and polls, Brokaw asks us to consider the total impact of our 9 year battle with the Taliban.

The media responds:

No comments:

Post a Comment